当前位置:首页 >> >>

Great Problems of Mathematics A Summer Workshop for High School Students


Great Problems of Mathematics: A Summer Workshop for High School Students
Reinhard C. Laubenbacher (reinhard@nmsu.edu) Department of Mathematical Sciences New Mexico State University, Las Cruces, NM 88003 Michael Siddoway (msiddoway@cc.colorado.edu) Department of Mathematics Colorado College, Colorado Springs, CO 80903 [College Mathematics Journal 25 (1994), 112-114]
Stimulating problems are at the heart of many great advances in mathematics. In fact, whole subjects owe their existence to a single problem that resisted solution. Nevertheless, throughout the curriculum we tend to present only polished theories and ?nished techniques, devoid of both the motivating problems and the long road to their solution. Why deprive our students of examples of the process by which mathematics is created? Why shield them from the central problems that have ?red its development? With these questions in mind, we designed a 3-week summer workshop for high school students, funded by the National Science Foundation under its Young Scholars program and held at Colorado College in 1992 and 1993. The 22 students who participated each summer were from across the country, were primarily beginning seniors, and had completed at least 2 years of algebra and 1 year of geometry. For an introduction to sophisticated mathematics that minimizes the prerequisites, we are convinced that our approach is e?ective, gets students excited, and is as suited to college as to high school [1]. We examined the evolution of selected great problems from set theory, number theory, and calculus using original sources. Studying primary sources 1

helps students to appreciate the progress over time in the clarity and sophistication of concepts and techniques. They also observe how progress can be blocked by certain ways of thinking, until some quantum leap takes us into a new era. Besides giving a ?rsthand look at the mathematical mindset of each period, no other method shows so clearly the evolution of mathematical rigor and the concept of what constitutes an acceptable proof. We used primarily a traditional lecture approach in the ?rst year, but in the second incorporated a combination of two pedagogical devices that proved amazingly e?ective: the “discovery” approach and daily writing. The “discovery” method assumes that students should discover the mathematics for themselves. Hence, for each source we brie?y provided the historical and mathematical context, alerted the students to any di?cult points in the text, and then stood by to answer questions while they worked through the source in pairs. A wrap-up discussion let everyone share his or her understanding of the material, and any remaining di?culties were resolved. This method generated tremendous enthusiasm and a genuine sense of discovery. Strikingly, we saw that it also led to a deeper understanding of the sources than the lecture approach had achieved the previous year. The students wrote frequently and about every aspect of the workshop: the mathematical details of the sources, their historical context, lecture notes from talks by guest speakers, thoughts jotted in the throes of problem solving, and their own ideas about the process that creates mathematics. Writing time was scheduled every day and, somewhat to our surprise, the students wrote proli?cally and generally quite well. This writing experience led to a more comprehensive view of the great problems we studied as well as a much better grasp of mathematical details in their solutions. To supplement the study of original sources, we discussed relevant problem solving techniques, and students paired up to choose research topics (e.g. G¨del’s incompleteness theorem, surreal numbers, Diophantine equao tions) which they ultimately presented as a paper. Besides guest speakers, we included prose readings of works by Einstein, Plato and Poincar?. e After the workshop, the students almost unanimously reported a dramatic shift in their concept of mathematics, from seeing it as a mere tool for the sciences to respecting “pure” and continuing mathematical research. They now saw the inherent fascination of problems, not just the utility of the solutions. The two versions of the workshop provided clear evidence of the inferiority 2

of lectures to a careful combination of small group discussion and guided study. Moreover, the utility of daily writing (which of course is old news in the humanities) was vividly demonstrated as a tool for comprehending and mastering mathematics. Regardless of pedagogic technique, however, the ability of primary source material to engage students’ attention and spur their e?orts was dramatically evident. A brief listing of our mathematical themes and original sources follows; [1] has a more detailed description with references. Set Theory. Cantor’s diagonal argument is the centerpiece of this topic. After his proof of the countability of the rational numbers (using a nonstandard order relation on the rationals) and the uncountability of the real numbers, we generalize the diagonal argument to produce in?nite sets of ever larger cardinality. Finally, we discuss his statement of the Continuum Hypothesis and its independence from the axioms of set theory. Fermat’s Last Theorem. From the determination of all Pythagorean triples in Euclid’s Elements, we leap to Euler’s proof of Fermat’s Last Theorem for exponent four, using Fermat’s method of in?nite descent. (Coincidentally, Andrew Wiles announced his proof of the theorem just before the second workshop ended.) Area, volume, and the de?nite integral. Archimedes’ computation of the area of a circle and Toricelli’s computation of the volume of an in?nite solid of revolution (using a precursor of the shell method) [2], leads to an excerpt from Cauchy’s Cours d’Analyse de?ning the modern version of the de?nite integral, using the limit concept.

References
[1] R. Laubenbacher and D. Pengelley, Great problems of mathematics: A course based on original sources, American Mathematical Monthly 99 (1992) 313-317. [2] Dirk J. Struik, A Source Book in Mathematics, 1200-1800, Princeton University Press, Princeton, 1986.

3


相关文章:
Great Problems of Mathematics A Summer Workshop for....pdf
Great Problems of Mathematics A Summer Workshop for High School Students_专业资料。Stimulating problems are at the heart of many great advances in ...
高三英语9月摸底考试试题(含解析).doc
A. To visit a store. problems. 16. What will...-week writing workshop for high school students....Summer at Penn Each summer, the University of ...
Thesis Title On Perfect Cuboids.pdf
Organizer of the workshop “Number Theory in Cryptography”, Bogot?, Fall...Co-leader of a mathematics summer camp for high school students for ...
福建省华安一中、长泰一中等四校2017-2018学年高二下学....doc
What problem are the speaks talking about? A. ...Workshop In the summer of 1983, Bard College ...-week writing workshop for high school students....
Summer School一览表.xls
for High School Students 11th grade (class of ...Mathematics and Science high school students (8th ...(RAP II) Global Studies Summer Workshop 2013: ...
Awards and Honors.pdf
Workshop on Sphere Packing (six lectures), ...mathematics of packing, Aspen Center for Physics,...a summer program for talented high school students...
SEMESTER REPORT SOSE 2007 MAREIKE MASSOW.pdf
One of the problems in this ?eld that I am ...Mathematics at TU Berlin; I gave a talk on ...a summer u school for highschool students in Gaes...
Macon County Summer Academy of Math (SAM)_图文.ppt
Macon County School District Summer Academy of ...Hands-on mathematics problem solving for students ...A lot of cooperative work… ? A lot of ...
09届高三英语上册第一次月考试卷.doc
C. Turn the basement into a workshop. 5. ...eye for ___ needs and welfare of the poor....school students, ___ to hospital immediately. A...
Education纽约圣约翰大学教育学学位解说【英文】.pdf
high school settings in: English, Mathematics, ...for students wishing to prepare as teachers of ...Workshop Child Abuse Workshop Autism Workshop (...
毕业论文外文翻译原文1.doc
in the high level material life very great ...workshop,three rotation,but only one officer per...for a clear understanding of mechanical science,...
CITIZENSHIP.pdf
a four week mathematical modeling workshop, ...programming laboratories for high school students. ...of Mathematics and Mechanical Engineering, Stanford ...
本科申请时间规划-4年计划_图文.pdf
b Attend a financial aid workshop with b ...Keep track of web addresses, high school ...summer months, participate in Apply for admission ...
Cambridge MSc Application.doc
What I am pursuing now is a master degree of ...I work for Kingston University as an assistant ...the students’ union in my high school as well...
scilab2006_图文.ppt
Applied mathematics, Artificial Intelligence, Information...The proceeding of workshop was published by ...SCILAB textbook for high school students by prof....
Zuowei_Shen_cv.pdf
of Mathematics, National University of Singapore ...Summer School of China, July-August, 2005, ...“ Interpolatory Subdivision Schemes”, Workshop on...
...and Recursion Theory, and Reverse Mathematics.pdf
? B.A. in Mathematics, with High Honors, ...AWM Workshop for Women Graduate Students and ...University of Minnesota Summer Research Fellowships ...
Publications.pdf
KDD-2004 Workshop on Multi- ? Parag and Pedro...Redmond Jul 06 - Sep 06 Position: Summer Intern...Discovery from Data Annals of Mathematics and ...
nselor Conference Te_图文.ppt
Preparation Workshop What does a teacher need to...high school teachers) Education Specialist (for ...? Current Areas of Need Mathematics Single Subject...
K20 Science Education Outreach Programs_图文.ppt
improving K-12 science and mathematics education....Summer workshop plus four quarterly meetings ...of Science for Tomorrow) Create a bioinformatics ...